$569,900
10451 Cottage Grove Drive
Beautiful 5 Bedroom, 3.5 Bathroom home on Hunter Lake with nearly an acre of land — a rare opportunity indeed! Fresh paint throughout, new mechanicals, a new roof, and a full set of Samsung Bespoke AI smart appliances (including washer and dryer) make this home truly move-in ready. The main-level primary suite is spacious and convenient, with three additional bedrooms and a full bath upstairs. The walkout basement includes a fifth bedroom, another full bath, a large family room, and a wet bar—perfect for entertaining or additional living space. Step outside to your semi-wooded, private backyard oasis. The updated dock sits on the channel, just moments from everything Hunter Lake has to offer: boating, fishing, and relaxation. All this, and still just minutes from downtown Middlebury.
From SR 120, go south on CR 43, then east onto Cottage Grove Dr. Home on north side.
1st Bdrm En Suite, Breakfast Bar, Built-In Bookcase, Cable Ready, Ceiling-9+, Closet(s) Walk-in, Deck Open, Deck on Waterfront, Disposal, Garage Door Opener, Patio Open, Porch Covered, Main Level Bedroom Suite, Main Floor Laundry
Sale IncludesDishwasher, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer, Window Treatments, Dryer-Gas, Oven-Gas, Range-Gas, Sump Pump, Water Filtration System, Water Heater Gas, Water Softener-Owned
Map to 10451 Cottage Grove Drive, Middlebury, IN 46540
MLS #
202547028
Date Listed
2025-11-22
Status
Active
Property Type
Residential
Property SubType
Site-Built Home
Finished Square Feet
3691 sqft
Total Square Feet
4056 sqft
New Construction
No
Style
Two Story
Type
Site-Built Home
Basement
Yes
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
4
(3 Full, 1 Half)
Annual Taxes
$4,226.42
Year Taxes Payable
2025
Year Built
2001
Virtual Tour
propertypanorama.com »
Days on Market
1
Additional
Design
Contemporary
Cooling
Central Air
Heating
Gas, Forced Air
Garage
Attached
Hardwood Floors
Yes
Main Level Laundry
Yes
Outbuilding
Shed
Room Dimensions
Living Room
15 × 23
Main Level
Dining Room
11 × 13
Main Level
Family Room
39 × 21
Lower Level
Kitchen
15 × 12
Main Level
Master Bedroom
16 × 15
Main Level
2nd Bedroom
15 × 11
Upper Level
3rd Bedroom
13 × 11
Upper Level
4th Bedroom
15 × 11
Upper Level
5th Bedroom
15 × 10
Lower Level
Extra Room
8 × 6
Lower Level
Bathroom Locations
Full Baths
1 Main, 1 Upper, 1 Lower
Half Baths
1 Main
External Features
Construction
Site-Built Home
Exterior
Vinyl
Lot Size
41,251 sq ft
Acreage
0.95 Acres
Lot Dimensions
131X315
Parking
No
Out Buildings
Shed
Sewer
Septic
Water
Well
Fence
None
Location
Area
Elkhart County
Location
Lake, Rural
County
Elkhart
Subdivision
None
Township
York
City
Middlebury
State
IN
Zip
46540
Schools
School District
Middlebury Community Schools
Elementary
York
Middle School
Northridge
High School
Northridge
Financial
Financing Terms
Cash, Conventional
Assoc. Dues
$0.00 Not Applicable
| MLS # | 202547028 |
|---|---|
| Date Listed | 2025-11-22 |
| Status | Active |
| Property Type | Residential |
| Property SubType | Site-Built Home |
| Finished Square Feet | 3691 sqft |
| Total Square Feet | 4056 sqft |
| New Construction | No |
| Style | Two Story |
| Type | Site-Built Home |
| Basement | Yes |
| Bedrooms | 5 |
| Bathrooms | 4 (3 Full, 1 Half) |
| Annual Taxes | $4,226.42 |
| Year Taxes Payable | 2025 |
| Year Built | 2001 |
| Virtual Tour | propertypanorama.com » |
| Days on Market | 1 |
| Design | Contemporary |
|---|---|
| Cooling | Central Air |
| Heating | Gas, Forced Air |
| Garage | Attached |
| Hardwood Floors | Yes |
| Main Level Laundry | Yes |
| Outbuilding | Shed |
| Living Room | 15 × 23 | Main Level |
| Dining Room | 11 × 13 | Main Level |
| Family Room | 39 × 21 | Lower Level |
| Kitchen | 15 × 12 | Main Level |
| Master Bedroom | 16 × 15 | Main Level |
| 2nd Bedroom | 15 × 11 | Upper Level |
| 3rd Bedroom | 13 × 11 | Upper Level |
| 4th Bedroom | 15 × 11 | Upper Level |
| 5th Bedroom | 15 × 10 | Lower Level |
| Extra Room | 8 × 6 | Lower Level |
| Full Baths | 1 Main, 1 Upper, 1 Lower |
| Half Baths | 1 Main |
| Construction | Site-Built Home |
|---|---|
| Exterior | Vinyl |
| Lot Size | 41,251 sq ft |
| Acreage | 0.95 Acres |
| Lot Dimensions | 131X315 |
| Parking | No |
| Out Buildings | Shed |
| Sewer | Septic |
| Water | Well |
| Fence | None |
| Area | Elkhart County |
|---|---|
| Location | Lake, Rural |
| County | Elkhart |
| Subdivision | None |
| Township | York |
| City | Middlebury |
| State | IN |
| Zip | 46540 |
| School District | Middlebury Community Schools |
|---|---|
| Elementary | York |
| Middle School | Northridge |
| High School | Northridge |
| Financing Terms | Cash, Conventional |
|---|---|
| Assoc. Dues | $0.00 Not Applicable |
MLS# 202547028
IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
Listing Provided Courtesy of Nicolas Wyse
RE/MAX Results
Office: 574-533-9581
Listing updated November 22, 2025 at 12:30 pm
Last checked 18 minutes ago
Learn More About 10451 Cottage Grove Drive
